Flexible working is poised to be the new predominant way of working, but are there alarm bells?
Flexible working is poised to be the new predominant way of working, but are there alarm bells?

8 minutes read

Flexible working is poised to be the new predominant way of working, but are there alarm bells?
Share on:
Posted:
05/09/2022
Author:
Category:

TL;DR: Flexible working is now the norm for many knowledge workers, and 36% of employed Australians usually work from home. The alarm bells are real but manageable. They include weaker connection, a gap between office and frontline staff, blurred working hours, and safety duties that follow people home.

Last updated 11 October 2026.

Key takeaways

  • According to the ABS, 59% of managers and professionals usually worked from home in August 2025, compared with 21% in all other occupations.
  • People who work from home are more likely to work overtime: 42%, against 26% of those who do not, according to the ABS.
  • According to Safe Work Australia, work health and safety duties apply at home just as they do in an office.
  • Since 26 August 2024, employees of businesses with 15 or more staff have had a right to disconnect outside working hours.
  • Most of the downsides come from how flexible work is managed, not from flexibility itself.

Is flexible working now the predominant way of working?

For knowledge workers, the answer is yes. According to the ABS, 59% of managers and professionals usually worked from home in August 2025. In addition, 30% of all employees had an agreement to work flexible hours. Across the whole workforce, 36% of employed people usually worked from home. For frontline roles, flexibility looks very different.

Of course, location flexibility only applies to part of the workforce. Retail and hospitality staff cannot serve customers their meals from home, and nor can nurses, tradespeople, or warehouse teams. That split is one of the alarm bells covered below.

The shift was decided during the pandemic. In 2021, Swinburne University’s Centre for the New Workforce surveyed more than 1,000 Australian knowledge workers. It found that 43% would be likely to leave an employer that did not offer flexible working. Home-based workers wanted 1.5 office days a week, flexible workers 2.8, and office-based workers 3.7.

As a result, an employer that wants to wind back flexible working will find it harder to attract and keep good people. Because flexible work has become an expectation, the question is no longer whether to offer it, but how to manage its risks.

These days, prospective hires don’t ask, “is there an option for flexible working?”, they ask, “how flexible are my working options?”

Are there problems with flexible working arrangements?

Yes, because as Oscar Wilde said, no good deed goes unpunished. In Swinburne’s 2021 research, flexible workers felt the least connected to their organisation and the least supported and trusted. They also had the lowest sense of meaning and purpose at work. They also reported being the least able to work effectively and get things done.

Those findings came from the first months of hybrid work, when few teams had worked out how to run it. Since then, the same themes have kept surfacing in guidance from regulators. For instance, Safe Work Australia lists poor support, low role clarity, and difficulty getting help from others among the hazards of working from home.

Consider a hybrid team where the manager is in the office on Mondays and the team comes in on Thursdays. Nobody plans it, so the team rarely sees its manager in person. Within a few months, newer staff feel unsupported, and decisions drift to whoever happens to be in the room.

The fix is rarely to scrap flexibility. Instead, set anchor days, train managers to lead people they cannot see, and use tools that keep everyone informed. With those in place, it is possible to engage and communicate well with a flexible workforce.

Does flexible working create a two-tier workforce?

It can, because location flexibility is concentrated in office roles, so frontline staff can feel the perks go to someone else. According to the ABS, 59% of managers and professionals usually work from home, against 21% of everyone else. Without flexibility over hours and rosters, that gap can feed resentment and turnover.

A second gap is visibility. Staff who are in the office more often can find it easier to be noticed, coached, and considered for promotion. So a manager who rates the people they see each day more highly is creating an equity problem, even without meaning to.

The gender dimension makes this sharper. According to the Workplace Gender Equality Agency (WGEA), flexible work is a key enabler of gender equality. However, if mostly women take it up and it quietly slows their careers, the policy can widen the gap it was meant to close.

The practical answer is to offer flexibility that fits each kind of role. A warehouse cannot offer home working, but it can offer predictable rosters, shift swapping, and part-time hours. Our guide to the types of flexible working sets out options for both office and frontline roles.

What work health and safety risks come with working from home?

According to Safe Work Australia, work health and safety laws apply when people work from home, just as they do in an office. Employers must manage risks so far as is reasonably practicable. Common hazards include a poor workstation, sedentary work, fatigue from being always on, and psychosocial hazards such as poor support or low role clarity.

The duty applies even when the employee asked to work from home. Safe Work Australia also says that if you cannot meet your duties for someone working from home, you must not require or agree to it. In practice, that means a home workstation checklist, regular check-ins, and a clear way to report a hazard.

Workers’ compensation also follows people home. According to Safe Work Australia, workers are generally covered while working from home, including during ordinary breaks. In addition, an employee working from home in a different state may need a different workers’ compensation policy, which catches out national employers.

Remote work fatigue deserves its own attention. Our article on remote work fatigue covers the psychosocial hazards and the practical steps for employers and employees.

Does flexible working blur working hours?

Often it does. According to the ABS, 42% of people who worked from home also worked overtime in August 2025, compared with 26% of those who did not. Catching up on work after hours was the third most common reason people gave for working from home. The right to disconnect now gives employees a legal backstop.

According to the Fair Work Ombudsman, employees can refuse to monitor, read, or respond to contact outside working hours, unless the refusal is unreasonable. The right has applied since 26 August 2024 for businesses with 15 or more employees, and since 26 August 2025 for small businesses.

The right does not ban out-of-hours contact outright. Instead, the reasonableness test weighs the reason for the contact, the employee’s role and pay, and their personal circumstances. So an email sent at 9 pm is not unlawful, but an expectation of a reply may be. Our explainer on the right to disconnect covers how the test works.

Which work suits home, and which suits the office?

Routine, focused work tends to suit home, while creative and collaborative work tends to suit the office. Swinburne’s research found workers most looked forward to the office to collaborate, connect, create, and learn. Productivity Commission findings suggested working from home can lift productivity through autonomy and concentration, but may hinder creativity and collaboration.

Part of the solution, then, is to plan what happens where. Coordinating tasks, writing, analysis, and maintaining usual outputs fit well at home. By contrast, informal chats, teamwork across groups, brainstorming, and onboarding new starters work better face to face.

So instead of a blanket rule on office days, a team can agree which activities need everyone together. For example, a finance team might hold planning, training, and month-end reviews in the office, and do reconciliations at home.

What legal risks come with refusing or withdrawing flexibility?

The main risk is mishandling a formal request. Under the Fair Work Act, eligible employees can request flexible working, and employers must respond in writing within 21 days. They can refuse only on reasonable business grounds after genuinely trying to agree. Since 2023, the Fair Work Commission can arbitrate disputes and make binding orders.

That process is covered in detail in our guide to flexible working requests. Return-to-office mandates add a further layer, and two Commission decisions show how a refusal can succeed or fail on its evidence.

Victoria may also add a state law of its own. The Equal Opportunity Amendment (Work from Home) Bill 2026 would create a right to work from home two days a week where reasonable. However, it is not law, and as at 11 October 2026 it had been referred to a Legislative Council select committee due to report on 20 October 2026.

Why is it still important to offer flexible working arrangements?

Because the benefits outweigh the risks when the risks are managed. According to WGEA, flexible work helps employers attract and keep diverse talent, and it is a key enabler of gender equality. It also helps parents, carers, and older workers stay in work, which matters as the workforce ages.

Making workplaces more flexible and responsive to employees’ needs is one of the main ways to attract and keep diverse talent. The alarm bells above do not argue against flexibility. Rather, they argue for running it deliberately: with clear policies, regular feedback, and attention to the people who cannot work from home.

Software can help with the routine parts of this. For instance, an HRIS such as Worknice can run short engagement surveys to spot falling connection early. It can also hold the flexible work policy with each employee’s acknowledgement. It also shows approved leave on a shared calendar, so teams can plan who is in. However, a small team that meets daily may get the same signal from a conversation.

Frequently asked questions

What are the disadvantages of flexible working for employers?

The main disadvantages are weaker team connection, harder supervision and coaching, a gap between office and frontline staff, and blurred working hours. Employers also keep their work health and safety duties for people working from home. Most of these risks can be managed with clear policies, anchor days, and regular check-ins.

Do work health and safety laws apply when employees work from home?

Yes. According to Safe Work Australia, employers must ensure the health and safety of workers working from home, so far as is reasonably practicable. That includes physical hazards, such as a poor workstation, and psychosocial hazards, such as high job demands or poor support. Workers must also take reasonable care of their own safety.

How many Australians work from home?

According to the ABS, 36% of employed Australians usually worked from home in August 2025, down from a peak of 40% in August 2021. The share is much higher for managers and professionals, at 59%, than for all other occupations combined, at 21%.

Can an employer stop flexible working arrangements?

It depends on how the arrangement was made. If it is in a contract, an enterprise agreement, or a Fair Work Commission order, the employer cannot simply withdraw it. Informal arrangements can usually change, but consult first, give reasonable notice, and treat any formal request under the Fair Work Act properly.

Is working from home a legal right in Australia?

There is no general right under federal law. Eligible employees can request flexible working under the Fair Work Act, and employers can refuse only on reasonable business grounds. Victoria has a bill that would create a right to work from home two days a week. As at 11 October 2026, however, it had not passed.

About the author

Graham Martin is Co-founder of Worknice, an Australian HRIS built for mid-to-large organisations. He has spent more than a decade working with Australian People and Culture teams on HR systems, compliance, and payroll integration.

Related reading

Sources

  1. Australian Bureau of Statistics, “Working arrangements, August 2025”. Released 12 December 2025. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/labour/earnings-and-working-conditions/working-arrangements/latest-release
  2. Swinburne University of Technology, “Hybrid or the highway for Australian workers: Swinburne research”. 20 October 2021. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.swinburne.edu.au/news/2021/10/hybrid-or-the-highway-for-Australian-workers-Swinburne-research/
  3. Safe Work Australia, “Working from home”, including “Overview”, “WHS duties”, “Managing risks”, and “Workers’ compensation”. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.safeworkaustralia.gov.au/safety-topic/managing-health-and-safety/working-home
  4. Fair Work Ombudsman, “Right to disconnect”. Content last updated 18 June 2026. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.fairwork.gov.au/employment-conditions/right-to-disconnect
  5. Workplace Gender Equality Agency, “Flexible work”. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.wgea.gov.au/flexible-work
  6. Productivity Commission, “Working from home”, research paper, 16 September 2021. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.pc.gov.au/inquiries-and-research/working-from-home/
  7. Victorian Government Solicitor’s Office, “Proposed new Victorian Work from Home (WFH) laws”. Updated 3 August 2026. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.vgso.vic.gov.au/proposed-new-victorian-work-home-wfh-laws
  8. HRD Australia, “Victoria’s work-from-home bill stalls as businesses claim ‘victory'”. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.hcamag.com/au/specialisation/benefits/victorias-work-from-home-bill-sent-for-committee-review/589393

Technology that ignites company culture

Worknice is a full lifecycle HR platform that bakes in performance and culture into everything it does. Find out more.

Read more

More articles you might like

  • HR Insights

    AI Agents for HR: What They Do, and What to Insist On

    TL;DR: AI agents for HR go beyond answering questions. They take steps in your HR system, such as sending paperwork or updating a record. Before one acts, ask four things: what it can change, whose permissions it uses, what needs confirmation, and how you check its work. Key takeaways What is an AI agent for […]

    7 mins read | 30/09/2026

    Read more
  • HR Insights

    AI Performance Reviews: What Helps, What to Avoid, and Rules to Set

    TL;DR: AI performance reviews work best when AI summarises feedback, spots patterns across a cycle, and drafts a first version. The manager rewrites that draft and decides the rating, and employee feedback never goes into a public chatbot. Set the rules before the cycle starts, because managers are already experimenting. Key takeaways Can AI write […]

    7 mins read | 30/09/2026

    Read more

Stay in the loop and subscribe now

Close Worknice uses cookies to improve your experience. By continuing you accept the use of cookies, in accordance with our Privacy Policy