When is it okay to refuse a request to work from home?
When is it okay to refuse a request to work from home?

9 minutes read

When is it okay to refuse a request to work from home?
Share on:
Posted:
07/02/2024
Author:
Category:

TL;DR: An employer can refuse an eligible employee’s request to work from home only after discussing it, genuinely trying to agree, and weighing the consequences for the employee. The refusal must also rest on specific reasonable business grounds. The Fair Work Commission upheld Maxxia’s refusal in 2023 but overturned Westpac’s in 2025, largely over evidence and process.

Last updated 11 October 2026.

Key takeaways

  • A request to work from home is a request to change the location of work, so section 65 of the Fair Work Act applies when the employee is eligible.
  • In *Gregory v Maxxia* (2023), the Commission upheld a refusal of 100% home-based work after the employer offered a staged hybrid alternative.
  • In *Chandler v Westpac* (2025), the Commission overturned a refusal because the bank missed the 21-day deadline, refused before discussing, and relied on general benefits.
  • A hybrid policy or enterprise agreement clause is not, by itself, a reasonable business ground for refusing an eligible request.
  • Victoria’s work from home bill was still before Parliament on 11 October 2026, so it is not yet law.

Can an employer refuse a request to work from home?

Yes, because working from home is not a general legal right in Australia. An employment contract can also require office attendance. However, an eligible employee can formally request to work from home, and the employer must then follow section 65A. That means a written response within 21 days and a refusal only on reasonable business grounds.

The issue of refusing work from home requests has reached the Fair Work Commission repeatedly since June 2023. That is when the Secure Jobs, Better Pay changes gave the Commission power to arbitrate disputes about flexible working arrangements. Before then, an employee whose request was refused had almost nowhere to take it.

So there are really two separate questions for the employer. First, is the employee eligible, meaning they have 12 months of service and a listed circumstance, such as caring for a school-age child or disability? Second, if they are, did the employer follow the process and have genuine grounds? A request that fails the first question sits outside the statutory scheme, although the employer can still agree to it.

Remote work is now one of the most requested arrangements, so this is where most disputes start. The types of flexible working explains the other options employees ask for, such as compressed hours or changed start times.

What happened in Gregory v Maxxia?

Maxxia’s hybrid policy required staff to work at least 40% of their hours in the office. An employee asked to work entirely from home, citing a planned custody arrangement and a medical condition. Maxxia offered a staged return instead, and in November 2023 the Commission found the refusal was on reasonable business grounds.

Background

The employee asked to work 100% of his full-time hours from home. He made the request on the basis that he was seeking a custody arrangement for his school-aged child, so he would care for the child every second week. He also attached a doctor’s letter about inflammatory bowel disease.

The employer felt he needed to spend some time in the office. According to the decision, his productivity was about 50% against a team target of 85%, and remote coaching had not lifted it. Maxxia was also the sole salary packaging provider to the South Australian Government, with a target of answering 99% of calls within three minutes. In addition, the employer wanted a long-tenured employee to contribute to team culture, training, and discussions with newer staff.

The employer responded the day after the request. It proposed 20% office attendance until the end of September 2023, rising to 40% from 2 October. It also offered to put his office days in the weeks he would not have custody. At the hearing, it added that he could work from home in custody weeks and vary his start, finish, and meal times for school runs.

On paper, that sounds reasonable, and the Commission agreed with the employer.

What did the Commission find?

Commissioner Platt noted that the employee’s contract required him to work in the office. While he had worked from home during the pandemic, the worst of the pandemic appeared to have passed. So the employer could require a return under the contract, unless the statutory process said otherwise.

The medical part of the request failed at the very first step. On the evidence, which was letters from an online doctor and no treatment plan, the Commission was not persuaded the condition was a disability. As a result, that part of the request was not a valid request under section 65, and the Commission had no power to arbitrate it.

The childcare limb was valid, but only for the weeks the employee would actually care for his son. For the other weeks, the Commission accepted that:

  • face-to-face contact within the team was desirable
  • being in the office would allow observation, interaction, and, if needed, coaching to improve his productivity and give him more support
  • less experienced colleagues could draw on his knowledge and experience more easily in person.

Based on this, it ordered that the refusal be taken to have been on reasonable business grounds. It declined to make any other order.

What happened in Chandler v Westpac?

A part-time Westpac employee, with the bank since 2002, asked to keep working from home so she could manage school drop-offs and pick-ups. Westpac’s policy required two office days a week, about two hours’ travel from her children’s school. In October 2025, the Commission found no reasonable business grounds and decided to order Westpac to grant the request.

The process failures were the first problem for the bank. Westpac conceded it did not respond within 21 days, since the request was made on 17 January 2025 and refused on 18 March. The first refusal gave no reasons, and the later reasons were described as “cursory at best”. Moreover, the manager did not discuss the request with her before refusing it. The Commission said the discussion and genuine attempt to agree should happen after the request and before the refusal, not afterwards.

Westpac’s business grounds also fell short of the test. Westpac described the benefits of office attendance for collaboration, team huddles, training, and mentoring. However, the Commission found that evidence generalised. Huddles and training already ran online, she had not mentored anyone since around 2022, and the bank made no attempt to quantify any loss. Her work could be done fully remotely, and she and her team were performing at a high level.

Fairness between the parties also weighed in her favour. The Commission accepted that her choice of home and school contributed to the problem. Even so, it found the consequences of refusing were seriously prejudicial for her family, while the benefit to Westpac was minimal. Finally, it rejected the argument that the bank’s enterprise agreement stopped it from making the order.

Why did one refusal succeed and the other fail?

The difference was not the arrangement requested. Maxxia engaged within a day, offered alternatives built around the employee’s actual caring weeks, and showed specific, measured business needs. Westpac refused late, without discussion, without written reasons, and relied on its policy and general benefits that its own evidence did not support.

Put side by side, the two cases turn on five practical things:

FactorGregory v Maxxia (2023)Chandler v Westpac (2025)
Response timeWritten proposal the day after the requestRefusal about two months later, past the 21-day limit
Discussion before refusalA meeting to discuss the proposalDiscussions only began after the refusal
Alternatives offeredStaged hybrid, office days outside custody weeks, flexible hoursCompromises offered later, then withdrawn for a less favourable position
Business evidenceSpecific service targets, measured productivity, a coaching needGeneral collaboration benefits, no attempt to quantify loss
Track record of remote workProductivity below target while at homeYears of high performance working remotely

These are first-instance decisions, so neither one sets a binding rule for later cases. Even so, both apply Full Bench guidance that the four refusal requirements in section 65A(3) are cumulative. In *Naden v Catholic Schools Broken Bay* [2025] FWCFB 82, failing to consider the consequences for the employee was enough to make a refusal invalid.

Is a return to office policy a reasonable business ground?

A policy alone is not enough. It shows what the business wants, but the Commission asks whether this particular arrangement, for this employee, would cause significant cost, productivity loss, or customer impact. Consistency across a team is a legitimate concern. However, it does not replace evidence about the role in front of you.

Maxxia’s manager wanted to keep hybrid expectations fair across the team, and the Commission accepted the refusal. Yet the decisive points were the productivity gap and the coaching need, not the 40% figure itself. By contrast, Westpac leaned heavily on its policy and lost the case.

The same applies to enterprise agreements. In *Paper Australia v May* [2025] FWCFB 224, a Full Bench upheld an order granting a request the employer had refused purely because of a rostering clause. A clause that cuts down the right to request flexible work has no effect to that extent, because the National Employment Standards sit above an agreement.

Employment contracts work differently, but only up to a point. A contract that names the office as the place of work lets you require attendance from someone who is not eligible to request flexibility. However, once an eligible employee makes a valid request, the section 65A process still applies.

How should you handle a work from home request you want to refuse?

Treat it as a process with a deadline, not a policy question. Check eligibility and the link to the circumstance, then meet the employee, explore alternatives, and record how a refusal would affect them. Finally, write down the specific business grounds and explain how they apply to this role.

Here is a practical sequence for HR teams to follow:

  1. Check eligibility. Confirm 12 months of service, a qualifying circumstance that exists now, and a written request that explains the reasons.
  2. Diary the 21 days. The clock starts on the valid request, and a late response counts against you even if your grounds are sound.
  3. Discuss before deciding. Meet the employee, understand the circumstance, and look for a partial arrangement, such as home-based days in caring weeks.
  4. Weigh the consequences. Record what refusing would mean for the employee, because the Commission will look for evidence that you considered it.
  5. Use role-specific evidence. Quantify the impact on service, productivity, or other staff where you can, and test it against how the role has performed remotely.
  6. Write a complete response. Include the reasons, the grounds and how they apply, any alternatives you would accept, and the employee’s right to take the dispute to the Commission.

Where do policies and records help?

A written working from home policy helps managers apply the same steps, as long as it does not become the only reason for a refusal. Pair it with a flexible work arrangements policy so requests on other grounds follow the same path.

For a workforce of several hundred, the paperwork is often where these cases are won or lost. An HRIS such as Worknice can keep the request, meeting notes, signed response, and policy acknowledgements on each employee’s record. That way, the history is ready if a dispute reaches the Commission. A smaller team with a handful of requests may manage with a well-kept shared folder.

Will Victoria create a legal right to work from home?

Not yet, because the bill has not passed. The Victorian Government introduced the Equal Opportunity Amendment (Work from Home) Bill 2026 on 16 June 2026. As introduced, it would give Victorian employees a right to work from home two days a week where reasonable. On 11 October 2026 it had passed the Legislative Assembly but was still before the Council.

Until a bill passes and commences, the Fair Work Act process above is the one that applies. If the Victorian bill does pass, its final terms may differ from the version introduced, so check the enacted text before changing any policy.

These cases will always be decided on their own facts. Still, the two decisions show how the Commission approaches them. It looks at the whole picture, including the process, the evidence, and the effect on both sides, and decides what is reasonable for that particular situation.

Frequently asked questions

Do employees have a legal right to work from home in Australia?

No general right exists under federal law. An eligible employee can request to work from home under section 65 of the Fair Work Act, and the employer can refuse only on reasonable business grounds after following the process. Victoria’s proposed work from home law had not passed as at 11 October 2026.

Can my employer force me to return to the office?

An employer can usually require office attendance if the employment contract names the workplace. However, an eligible employee can make a written flexible work request. The employer must then respond within 21 days, discuss it genuinely, consider the consequences, and refuse only on reasonable business grounds, or the Commission may intervene.

What are reasonable business grounds to refuse working from home?

Reasonable business grounds include excessive cost, no capacity to rearrange other employees’ work, impractical recruitment, and a likely significant loss of productivity or customer service. In 2023 the Commission accepted specific needs for face-to-face coaching and team support. General collaboration benefits, without evidence for the particular role, did not persuade it in 2025.

What did the Fair Work Commission decide in the Westpac work from home case?

In Chandler v Westpac Banking Corporation, decided in October 2025, the Commission found Westpac had no reasonable business grounds to refuse an employee’s request to work from home. Westpac had also missed the 21-day deadline and refused before discussing the request. The Commission decided to order Westpac to grant it.

Is a hybrid work policy enough to refuse a work from home request?

No. A policy on its own does not show that a particular arrangement would cause significant cost, productivity loss, or customer impact. The Commission looks at the specific role and employee. Consistency across a team is relevant, but it needs supporting evidence, and an enterprise agreement clause cannot override the statutory right.

About the author

Graham Martin is Co-founder of Worknice, an Australian HRIS built for mid-to-large organisations. He has spent more than a decade working with Australian People and Culture teams on HR systems, compliance, and payroll integration.

Related reading

Sources

  1. Fair Work Commission, *Gregory v Maxxia Pty Ltd* [2023] FWC 2768, 16 November 2023. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/decisionssigned/pdf/2023fwc2768.pdf
  2. Fair Work Commission, *Chandler v Westpac Banking Corporation* [2025] FWC 3115, 20 October 2025, including its summary of *Paper Australia Pty Ltd v May* [2025] FWCFB 224. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/decisionssigned/pdf/2025fwc3115.pdf
  3. Fair Work Commission, *Naden v Catholic Schools Broken Bay Limited* [2025] FWCFB 82, 22 April 2025. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/decisionssigned/pdf/2025fwcfb82.pdf
  4. Fair Work Ombudsman, “Flexible working arrangements”. Content last updated 10 August 2026. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.fairwork.gov.au/employment-conditions/flexibility-in-the-workplace/flexible-working-arrangements
  5. Federal Register of Legislation, “Fair Work Act 2009”. Compilation C2026C00355, 7 July 2026, sections 65 to 65C. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.legislation.gov.au/C2009A00028/latest/text
  6. Victorian Government Solicitor’s Office, “Proposed new Victorian Work from Home (WFH) laws”. 19 June 2026, updated 3 August 2026. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.vgso.vic.gov.au/proposed-new-victorian-work-home-wfh-laws
  7. Victorian Legislation, “Bills in Parliament”, Equal Opportunity Amendment (Work from Home) Bill 2026, status “Council, second reading (passed Assembly)”. Retrieved 11 October 2026: https://www.legislation.vic.gov.au/bills/in-parliament

Let’s Grow Together

Talk to us about your plans and discover how Worknice can help you build a great company.

Homepage

More articles you might like

  • HR Insights

    AI Agents for HR: What They Do, and What to Insist On

    TL;DR: AI agents for HR go beyond answering questions. They take steps in your HR system, such as sending paperwork or updating a record. Before one acts, ask four things: what it can change, whose permissions it uses, what needs confirmation, and how you check its work. Key takeaways What is an AI agent for […]

    7 mins read | 30/09/2026

    Read more
  • HR Insights

    AI Performance Reviews: What Helps, What to Avoid, and Rules to Set

    TL;DR: AI performance reviews work best when AI summarises feedback, spots patterns across a cycle, and drafts a first version. The manager rewrites that draft and decides the rating, and employee feedback never goes into a public chatbot. Set the rules before the cycle starts, because managers are already experimenting. Key takeaways Can AI write […]

    7 mins read | 30/09/2026

    Read more

Stay in the loop and subscribe now

Close Worknice uses cookies to improve your experience. By continuing you accept the use of cookies, in accordance with our Privacy Policy