Most modern awards let an employer direct an employee to take excess annual leave once the balance passes 8 weeks. For a shiftworker, the threshold is 10 weeks. First, you must genuinely try to agree. Then give a written direction with at least 8 weeks’ notice. It must cover at least one week and leave 6 weeks accrued.
Key takeaways
- According to the Fair Work Ombudsman, excess annual leave is typically more than 8 weeks accrued, or 10 for a shiftworker.
- A direction only becomes available after you have genuinely tried to agree, including where the employee refuses to confer.
- Under the Clerks Award, directed leave must start between 8 weeks and 12 months after the direction is given.
- A direction that would leave less than 6 weeks accrued has no effect, so count booked leave first.
- Leave balances usually sit in payroll, so the process starts with a balance report HR and managers can see.
What counts as excess annual leave under a modern award?
Under most modern awards, an employee has an excessive leave accrual once they have accrued more than 8 weeks of paid annual leave, or more than 10 weeks for a shiftworker. Awards say excessive leave accrual and the Fair Work Ombudsman says excess annual leave, but both terms describe the same balance.
According to the Fair Work Ombudsman, full-time and part-time employees get 4 weeks of annual leave a year. So a balance above 8 weeks means roughly two years of leave has gone untaken. The balance tends to build quietly, for ordinary reasons. A manager never hands over, a long-serving employee saves for a trip, or a stretched team cannot release anyone.
Each untaken week is also money the business owes, which is why finance teams watch annual leave liability closely. However, the stronger reason to act is rest, because people who never take a break tire, make mistakes, and become single points of failure.
Where do the 8 week and 10 week thresholds come from?
The thresholds come from a model excessive leave term, which the Fair Work Commission wrote during its 4 yearly review of modern awards. A Full Bench settled the wording in September 2015, and the term now appears in most modern awards. In the Clerks Private Sector Award 2020, for example, it sits in clauses 32.6 to 32.8.
The 10 week threshold applies only to a shiftworker as the award defines one. Under the Clerks Award, that means someone regularly rostered to work Sundays and public holidays. In addition, the business must roster shifts continuously, 24 hours a day and 7 days a week. Therefore an employee who simply works evenings may still sit under the 8 week threshold.
Excessive leave award provisions follow the same pattern. However, the Fair Work Ombudsman warns that the rules can differ between awards. So read the clause in the award that covers each employee before you rely on a general figure.
When can an employer force annual leave on an employee?
An employer can force annual leave only where an award, an enterprise agreement, or the Fair Work Act allows it, and only if the requirement is reasonable. For excess leave under most awards, two things must be true first. The balance has passed the threshold, and you have genuinely tried to agree with the employee.
Section 93 of the Fair Work Act lets an award or enterprise agreement require an employee to take paid annual leave in particular circumstances, but only if the requirement is reasonable. According to the Fair Work Ombudsman, the two common situations are a shutdown and an excess balance. Outside those situations, leave is taken at a time the employee and employer agree.
So the direction is a last step, and three things come before it. The employee has an excessive leave accrual, you have tried to reach agreement, and that attempt has failed.
What does genuinely trying to agree look like?
Clause 32.6 of the Clerks Award says either side may seek to confer with the other and genuinely try to agree on how to reduce or eliminate the excess. The award sets no script for that conversation, so the format is yours. In practice, you meet the employee, show them the balance, and ask when they would like to take leave.
Suppose a warehouse supervisor has 11 weeks accrued and says the team cannot cope without her. A genuine attempt offers her real options. For instance, propose a block in the quiet season, a run of long weekends, or cover arranged by her manager. Then you confirm the outcome in writing, whichever way it goes.
An agreed plan is the better result, because the employee picks the dates, the balance falls, and nobody receives a formal letter.
What if the employee will not engage?
Under clause 32.7, the power to direct arises when agreement is not reached. That includes an employee who refuses to confer. As a result, your record of the attempt matters. Note the date you asked, who attended, what you offered, and how the employee responded. Without that record, you cannot show the first step happened.
What must a written direction to take excess annual leave include?
A written direction to take excess annual leave must name the period or periods of leave and meet four conditions. It must leave at least 6 weeks accrued, cover at least one week per period, and fit any leave already agreed. In addition, the leave must start between 8 weeks and 12 months after the direction is given.
The Clerks Award sets these out in clause 32.7(b). The same four also appear in the Fair Work Commission’s model term.
| Condition | What clause 32.7(b) requires |
|---|---|
| Remaining balance | At least 6 weeks must stay accrued at all times, counting other leave arrangements |
| Minimum period | No period of directed leave may be shorter than one week |
| Notice window | Leave must begin at least 8 weeks, and at most 12 months, after the direction |
| Existing arrangements | The direction must not be inconsistent with any leave arrangement already agreed |
How do you work out the 6 week floor?
Start with the balance, subtract leave already booked, and then subtract 6 weeks. Whatever remains is the most you can direct at that point. For instance, the supervisor with 11 weeks has 2 weeks approved over Christmas. That leaves 9 weeks, so a direction can cover at most 3 weeks.
The floor mostly catches people who sit near the threshold. Suppose someone has 8.5 weeks accrued and 3 weeks already approved. Any direction would push the remaining balance below 6 weeks, so it would have no effect. In that case, the booked leave is already doing the job.
What happens after the direction is given?
The employee must take the leave as directed while the direction is in effect. However, they can still request other leave as if no direction existed, and you must not unreasonably refuse. If that extra leave would push the balance below 6 weeks, the direction may cease to have effect. So recheck the numbers whenever a new request arrives.
The Fair Work Ombudsman publishes a free direction to take excessive annual leave template, with instructions and a sample letter. Its worked example has an employee with 12 weeks accrued. Her employer directs her to take 3 weeks of leave in 3 months’ time. That direction clears every condition, because it is written, longer than one week, and more than 8 weeks away. It also leaves 9 weeks accrued.
Can an employee with excess annual leave insist on taking it?
Yes, under most awards. An employee who has had an excessive leave accrual for more than 6 months can give written notice requiring leave. Agreement must have been genuinely tried first, and no employer direction can already clear the excess. In that case, the employer must grant the leave requested.
Clause 32.8 of the Clerks Award mirrors the employer’s side. Because the conditions match, the employee’s notice must leave at least 6 weeks accrued, cover at least one week per period, and fit any leave already agreed. Leave must also start between 8 weeks and 12 months after the notice. In addition, an employee cannot require more than 4 weeks in any 12 months this way. For a shiftworker, that cap is 5 weeks.
This right changes the conversation for managers who keep deferring. Suppose a team leader keeps declining a long-serving employee’s requests because the roster is always tight. After 6 months above the threshold, that employee can name the dates, give 8 weeks’ notice, and take the leave. Therefore saying “not now” indefinitely stops working, and planning cover early becomes the cheaper path.
How do the rules differ for award-free and enterprise agreement employees?
Award-free and agreement-free employees can be required to take paid annual leave if the requirement is reasonable, under section 94 of the Fair Work Act. Enterprise agreement employees, by contrast, follow the agreement’s own terms. Where an agreement allows a direction without setting rules, the direction must be reasonable.
According to the Fair Work Ombudsman, a requirement can be reasonable when the employee’s leave balance is excessive. However, the Act sets no 8 week threshold, no 6 week floor, and no fixed notice period for these employees. Those numbers belong to award clauses, so they do not apply automatically to an award-free senior manager.
What makes a requirement reasonable?
The explanatory memorandum to the Fair Work Bill listed considerations for judging a requirement under an award or agreement term. It named the needs of both the employee and the business, any agreed arrangement, the custom and practice in the business, the timing of the requirement, and the notice given. A Fair Work Commission Full Bench quoted that list when it settled the model term.
Because of that, a cautious employer borrows the award pattern for award-free staff. Talk first, give generous written notice, and leave a sensible balance behind. That is a benchmark rather than a rule, so take advice where the stakes are high.
What should you check in an enterprise agreement?
Read the annual leave clause for three things. Check whether it allows a direction at all, what threshold it sets, and what notice it requires. Many workforces are also mixed. For example, award-covered administrators, agreement-covered site staff, and award-free executives may share one payroll. So record which instrument covers each person, because the same balance triggers different rules.
Is a shutdown direction the same as directing excess annual leave?
No, a shutdown direction is a separate mechanism, used when all or part of a business closes for a period, such as between Christmas and New Year. Each award sets its own shutdown notice rules. In addition, the excessive leave clauses do not apply to leave taken during a shutdown.
Under clause 32.5 of the Clerks Award, the employer gives affected employees 28 days’ written notice of the shutdown, or a shorter period agreed with the majority of them. The direction itself must be in writing and must be reasonable. For award-free and agreement-free employees, the Fair Work Ombudsman again applies the reasonableness test.
The two mechanisms answer different problems, so keep them apart. A shutdown applies to everyone affected by the closure, whatever their balance. An excess leave direction, by contrast, applies to one person and depends on their balance. It also follows a failed attempt to agree. A shutdown is also different from a stand down, which covers work stopping for reasons outside the employer’s control.
Cashing out is a third route, and it cannot be directed. It needs the employee’s written agreement, and the annual leave cash out rules carry their own limits.
How do you find excess leave balances and keep a record of the direction?
Find excess balances by running a leave balance report from payroll on a fixed schedule and flagging everyone above 8 weeks, or 10 weeks for shiftworkers. Then keep a dated record of each step. That record covers the conversation, the agreed plan or written direction, and the leave once it is taken.
The whole process depends on a number most people cannot see. Leave accrues in payroll, so the balance often lives in a system that only payroll staff open. Managers approve requests without knowing who is carrying 9 weeks. Employees, meanwhile, guess at their own balance, and HR learns about the problem at year end.
How often should you review balances?
Review balances on a fixed rhythm, such as each quarter. Then sort the report into people over the threshold, approaching it, and well under it. People approaching the threshold matter most, because an early conversation usually ends in an agreed plan. Then send each manager their own list, so the first discussion happens in a regular catch-up.
Visibility for employees helps as much as reports for HR. For example, Worknice shows employees the leave balances their payroll system holds, such as Xero or KeyPay, alongside their requests. Payroll stays the source of truth. A connected time off management tool simply puts that figure in front of the people deciding.
What records should you keep?
Keep one trail per person, in date order. Start with the balance on the review date and the meeting notes, then add the agreed plan or direction letter, and proof of when the employee received it. The date matters most, because the 8 week and 12 month window runs from the day the direction is given.
According to the Fair Work Ombudsman, employee records must be kept for 7 years. Leave records must also show leave taken and the balance. A direction letter stored in an inbox is hard to produce later. So file it against the employee, where employee document management keeps letters, acknowledgements, and dates together.
Which tools suit this process?
Three tools cover the job: payroll holds the balance, a leave system handles requests and approvals, and a document store keeps the trail. How they connect matters more than which brand you pick. In particular, check that balances flow from payroll through a payroll integration, so nobody retypes them.
If you keep your existing payroll and want balances, requests, and approvals visible in one place, Worknice is a sensible option for organisations of 50 to 1,000 people. It shows the balances payroll holds and does not forecast future accruals. So a business wanting leave forecasting inside its HR system may prefer a different platform. The same goes for one wanting a single vendor for HR and payroll.
Frequently asked questions
Can an employer force an employee to take annual leave in Australia?
Yes, but only in limited situations. An award or enterprise agreement can allow it, most often for a shutdown or an excess leave balance, and the requirement must be reasonable. Award-free and agreement-free employees can be required to take leave on the same reasonableness test. Otherwise, leave is taken at a time both sides agree.
How many weeks of annual leave is considered excessive?
Under most modern awards, more than 8 weeks of accrued paid annual leave counts as an excessive leave accrual. For a shiftworker, as the award defines one, the threshold is more than 10 weeks. Enterprise agreements can set different thresholds, and the Fair Work Act sets none for award-free employees.
How much notice must an employer give to direct excess annual leave?
Under most modern awards, directed leave cannot begin less than 8 weeks after the written direction is given, or more than 12 months after it. The direction must cover at least one week and leave the employee with at least 6 weeks accrued. Shutdown directions, by contrast, follow separate notice rules.
Can an employee refuse a direction to take excess annual leave?
Under most awards, an employee must take leave in line with a valid direction. However, a direction has no effect if it would leave less than 6 weeks accrued. The employee can also still request other leave as if no direction existed. In addition, the employer must not unreasonably refuse that request.
Can you direct an award-free employee to take excess annual leave?
Yes, if the requirement is reasonable. The Fair Work Ombudsman says an excessive balance can make a requirement reasonable for award-free and agreement-free employees. However, the award numbers do not apply automatically. So weigh the employee’s needs, the business’s needs, the timing, and the notice you give.
About the author
Graham Martin is Co-founder of Worknice, an Australian HRIS built for mid-to-large organisations. He has spent more than a decade working with Australian People and Culture teams on HR systems and payroll integration.
This article is general information only and is not legal advice. For advice on your specific obligations, speak to a qualified professional.
Related reading
- Leave calendar and overlap visibility: how seeing who else is away helps managers approve the leave an agreed plan depends on.
- Sample leave and time off policy: a starting point for writing your excess leave process into policy before you need it.
- What makes an HRIS Fair Work compliant: where an HR system helps with record-keeping duties, and where payroll still does the work.
- Employee records in Worknice: one place for each person’s details, documents, and history.
Sources
- Fair Work Ombudsman. “Direction to take excess annual leave.” Fair Work Ombudsman, content last updated 7 August 2026, retrieved 18 November 2026. https://www.fairwork.gov.au/leave/annual-leave/directing-an-employee-to-take-annual-leave/direction-to-take-excess-annual-leave
- Fair Work Ombudsman. “Directing an employee to take annual leave.” Fair Work Ombudsman, content last updated 15 October 2026, retrieved 18 November 2026. https://www.fairwork.gov.au/leave/annual-leave/directing-an-employee-to-take-annual-leave
- Fair Work Ombudsman. “Direction to take annual leave during a shutdown.” Fair Work Ombudsman, content last updated 7 August 2026, retrieved 18 November 2026. https://www.fairwork.gov.au/leave/annual-leave/directing-an-employee-to-take-annual-leave/direction-to-take-annual-leave-during-a-shut-down
- Fair Work Commission. “Clerks Private Sector Award 2020 (MA000002)”, clauses 32.2 and 32.5 to 32.9. Consolidated to 26 October 2026, retrieved 18 November 2026. https://awards.fairwork.gov.au/MA000002.html
- Fair Work Commission Full Bench. “4 yearly review of modern awards: Annual leave, [2015] FWCFB 5771.” Fair Work Commission, September 2015, retrieved 18 November 2026. https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/decisionssigned/html/2015fwcfb5771.htm
- Commonwealth of Australia. “Fair Work Act 2009”, sections 88, 93 and 94. Federal Register of Legislation, retrieved 18 November 2026. https://www.legislation.gov.au/C2009A00028/latest/text
- Fair Work Ombudsman. “Annual leave.” Fair Work Ombudsman, content last updated 15 October 2026, retrieved 18 November 2026. https://www.fairwork.gov.au/leave/annual-leave
- Fair Work Ombudsman. “Record-keeping and pay slips fact sheet.” Fair Work Ombudsman, content last updated 16 January 2026, retrieved 18 November 2026. https://www.fairwork.gov.au/tools-and-resources/fact-sheets/rights-and-obligations/record-keeping-pay-slips